1310
« on: November 27, 2007, 07:39:13 am »
"In BLACK PANTHER vol. 2, # 21, page 7, Priest recapped both the IM annual and OVER THE EDGE issues and the fact that those were cases where he was raised from the dead and animated via the Mandarin and Klaw, respectively. So he wasn't quite himself I would say;-)
"
Hi all:
SPOILERS!!!
I went through my Priest era collection and sadly found that I didn't have v.II, #21. Not that I doubt Bob, who I recognize as most knowlegeable on BP for everything up to and including the Priest era, (Bob knows I'm a big fan, especially of his run with Sal on BP). However if you read the "Over the Hedge issue" (#6) Marvel clearly establishes Kilmonger as the real deal, he was very much himself, and sets this up as a definitive battle between T'challa and he. In fact, on page 10 (there are no page numbers so I counted the pages w/o ads) Killmonger explains how BP's second encounter with him, referenced by an editor's note as having occurred in Iron Man Annual #5, was actually with a "Simalicrum" constructed by the Mandarin with whom he made a pact to see how T'challa would react to his return. On page 9 Killmonger actully refers to the Wakandan boy Kantu that actually saved T'challa in their first encounter.
I don't think this is a case where Preist messed up, especially since he addressed it in v.II, #21. I think he used dramatic license because he wanted to foster this notion of T'challa having a foe he'd never been able to truly beat. I don't know if that's because of the flak he was getting for making BP, "too powerful" or if he simply had this McGregor-ish notion of T'challa as this ultimately, vulnerable superhero. The whole aneurism plot and the fact that I never saw Preist as one to cave to pressure leads me to believe the latter. While I did not like the aneurism idea, this is in no way a criticism of Preist or McGregor, I loved the majority of their work. I do believe however, that Marvel set-up the "Over the Hedge" showdown between BP and Killmonger to resolve the first encounter between the two, over Warrior Falls in Wakanda (I think that's where it happened? Bob?)
Anyway, it's a very satisfying story. I highly recommend it!
Happy Holidays all!
Peace,
Mont