Rutog is imo reasonable well balanced and sensible, and he wrote a very good post above. His extreme passion for STORM is very obvious, and while it sometimes leads him to opinions occupying the outer fringes for those of us who o not follow Storm with the intensity and dare I say borderline fanaticism that he does...what he always shows is a deep knowledge of and a solid grasp of the material he posts.
There is always something compelling about his posts. Whether or not we agree with him.
And he's right about Pak. He's right that Storm would take Logan's death very hard and it will have a heavy impact upon her. It SHOULD do so. Given the DECADES they spent together, their romantic relationship...how could it not?
lf T'Challa died? She'd be prostrate, too.
I expect her to seek vengeance on the murderers of Logan...or a at least I expect her to do so if she's allowed by the X-Office to play a role in any kind of "get back" for Logan's death. I would expect the same...if Pak was writing her, and if he wasn't handcuffed by the X-Office and/or Editorial...if TChalla died or was severely injured.
This woman stood off Death itself for TChalla. Under RH's pen. Fighting Death's minions to a standstill is nearly on par with housing the essence of ETERNITY. Fighting a running battle with The Super Zombies while everyone else was getting eaten by them? Yeah, let's give her feats under RH's pen their props. The Super Skrull arc was basically The Storm Show. She beat down everyone, plus she rescued TChalla. TWICE.
Bringin that up off of the top of my head just to make it clear that Storm wasn't second fiddle to anyone under RH's pen.
Other than the points listed above, and the fact that I am one of the lone wolves on this forum that openly loves EJD's miniseries and finds it superior to the original CC script BY LIGHTYEARS [ if I see supertech supergenius TChalla in a old skool loincloth again, dealing with pathetic tech group flunkies and some Bull guy who wouldn't even rate a second look from the Dora Milaje, I'm assassinating the writer ] and other than having my doubts about Hickman reducing Storm to a "booty call" and even more dubious am I about Hickman remotely trying to spark back up the marriage between TChalla and Storm--more likely a passionate but troubled connection highlighting the character strengths and quirks of each character, given his long game and character focused style--I pretty much agree with what Rutog wrote above.
Once again, Brother, your ability to see all sides of an issue and the extraordinary patience which allows you to do so is illuminated in your observation.
Rutog is what you say. Our Brothers on the other hand, have an opinion which they've formulated through time and experience with respect to Rutog at variance with your own. Salustrade, Seven, Genki Sudo, Kimoyo, Booshman have gone toe-to-toe with the denizens of that other place (CBR). The x-fanatics there would test the limits of even your considerable patience, Supreme.
As you know, that entire forum was purged to rid itself of individuals who allowed their passions to boil over to the point where some might have attempted a near-criminal act on the object of their ire. Salustrade, Seven and the others have confronted and are confronting mindsets and opinions not unlike in many respects to those purged CBR members every other day, if not daily. A steady diet of that can be irritating. They are bizarre, Supreme. I know. I've been there. I can see how Booshman - who has mentioned more than once Rutog's CBR activities - might be sort of abrupt with Rutog in their discourse. Jenn has seen the worst of internet forums where fanatics of an intolerable and racist bent have given vent to their idiocy and she has evinced little patience with Rutog. Princessa of all people has referred to Rutog as a troll. And Kip...even Kip struck me as perhaps becoming mildly irritated (?) by some of Rutog's sometimes over-the-top descriptions of Storm's power levels.
I give it up to Rutog. He's standing his ground. He was wrong about Storm being written as second fiddle to Shuri. The way the story was written, if not for Storm's mild rebuke of Ramonda and her confidence in Shuri at a time when Ororo showed her TRUE STRENGTH OF CHARACTER functioning as Queen of Wakanda while her husband fought for his life, Shuri would not be the Black Panther today. Shuri is the Black Panther BECAUSE OF STORM. Wolverine gets kudos for transforming a "little punkin" into a Shadowcat. Storm's contribution to Wakanda and to the lineage of the Black Panther is ignored. Many Storm fans are afflicted with this tunnel vision. Rutog is one such.
Still, Rutog deserves a respectful reading and from what I've seen, he has attempted to be respectful when responding to rebuts to his debate points.
Couple of things I'd like to point out:
1) Storm was definitely written down as second fiddle to Shuri. When Doom attacked Panther and nearly killed him, Shuri was the one who went out looking for answers, not Storm. This was TOTALLY out-of-character for Ororo. Storm is a very proactive leader. No power on Earth would have stopped Storm from hunting down T'challa's attacker, yet Shuri got the shine here. During "Mutant Massacre", when Mr. Sinister sent his Marauders out to decimate the Morlocks, Storm sent Wolverine out to KILL, that's right, KILL the Marauders. She told him that she needed only one of them brought back to her alive. When she thought Magneto had killed Shadowcat in a story, Storm was prepared to take Magneto on solo in a fight to the death and take his life. When Marrow had a bomb attached to her heart that was going to explode and kill thousands of citizens, people Storm didn't even know, she engaged Marrow in a knife fight and killed her by cutting out her heart. Of course, it was revealed much later that Marrow actually has two hearts to bring her back to life. Recently, in Amazing X-Men (July's issue), she was concerned for Logan when he went up to Canada on his own and had Rachel Grey use Cerebro to scan for his location. She forbade Logan to leave the mansion because he is vulnerable without his healing factor. When Rachel was having difficulty locating him, Storm showed little patience and threatened to replace Rachel with her teenaged mother, Jean Grey. Now, Storm was not married to any of these people, but she chose to marry Panther, which means she loves him. So, yes, Storm was written as second fiddle to Shuri because it was Shuri who took on this role after the assault on T'challa while Ororo was portrayed as this wimpy, weeping wife so distraught over her husband's assault that she was just too emotionally fragile to do anything. Storm is MUCH tougher than that. Her strength of character and fierceness was written down to prop up Shuri. Maberry obviously doesn't know Storm's character or simply didn't care as all he wanted to do was give Shuri the limelight. Storm should have had Logan sniffing around the wreckage for clues, she should have Emma Frost on Cerebro scanning for clues as to Panther's attacker. Heck, she probably would have had Emma use Cerebro to sneak into Panther's mind clear over from America while Panther was in Africa behind his back to ascertain the identity of his attacker. She would have been out there interrogating people and even threatening them for information. Yes, I said threaten. The first time she and Candra crossed swords, Candra had invaded Achmed el-Gibar's home (Ororo's thief mentor back from her childhood days on the streets of Cairo) and convinced one of his street urchins to come with her. Candra's plans were to exploit his latent mutant abilities for herself. Achmed asked Ororo to save the boy from her corruption. In an attempt to locate Candra, she interrogated people and used intimidation to extract information from people as she worked her way through the criminal underground of the city.
Had this been an "in-character" Storm when Maberry took over? Emma would have found out from Panther's mind not only the identity of the attacker, Doom, but also about the nannite threat not only in her bloodstream, but in the bloodstream of every Wakandan citizen from Panther's mind. T'challa avoided telling Storm or anybody else about Doom since Doom would have immediately known that he told somebody through those same nannites. Emma, would have also gleaned this from Panther's mind as she probed his thoughts and memories and alerted Storm to this threat telepathically where Doom would be unable to detect Storm's knowledge of it. Emma would have likely told Ororo aloud (for Doom's sake) that she was unable to get anything out of Panther's head while telepathically telling Ororo EVERYTHING. Storm would have then mentally instructed Emma to telepathically instruct Forge or Beast come up with an antidote for the nannite infection. She would have then somehow come up with a way to instantly disperse this antidote to the entire population simultaneously and it would be a toss up as to whether or not Storm would charge over to Latveria on her own to rain down the fury of the elements upon Doom's head or if she would have restrained herself for a more concerted attack against Doom working with Shuri, T'challa and the Wakandan military.
2) I don't know what happened on CBR with the other Storm fans vs. Panther fans as I didn't get involved in the online fights over the Storm/BP marriage. I didn't even read the discussions going on there as I had already made up my own mind on the marriage situation. I believe the Storm fans definitely have some legitimate gripes about the whole ordeal (and I share some of those with them as I have outlined my complaints with the sloppy, unrealistic way the two characters were just thrown together in the marriage without any realistic build up, that TERRIBLE mini that brought down Storm and Ororo being written as second fiddle to that third stringer, Shuri). However, I told you guys at length about how I saw the positive potential in such a union. I voiced this overthere as well. Also, remember how I told you it was hotly debated on the internet for years who Storm should be with prior to her marrying Panther? Guess what? Surprise, my first choice for Storm to marry was the BLACK PANTHER in those debates. My second choice was Nightcrawler. He was the only one I thought who was formal enough in manner, gentlemanly and mature enough to be with her. Also, he wasn't pining over the other X-Men like Wolverine was over Jean...well, not going to go on and on about that. Though I never read Panther's title or stories with him save the Priest and original tellings of how he and Ororo met, I liked the idea of the two of them together. That said, I have already voiced my gripes on how the two characters were just SLOPPILY thrown together in an unrealistic way that hurt Storm's character in an effort to rush this forced marriage. It did not feel like a natural progression AT ALL for the two to marry as soon as they did. At any rate, I don't have to repost my arguments on this. To finish this point, I should say that I have never bashed Panther or Hudlin on any thread or forum. Also, I am who I am. I don't come on these boards and say one thing while going on CBR or any other board saying something completely different. So, I don't know what you mean by CBR activities I've been engaging in. I stand behind what I say. I don't change my opinion when I go from one audience to another.
3) You mention that I mildly irritate KIP, right? Perhaps I need to work on that...NOT. He needs to get with the program. KIP is used to me by now...or at least he should be.

We've known each other for years. We butt heads, but we like each other. We used to chat on IM, even, and we get on well. Sometimes, we would debate Storm on those IM conversations. He doesn't feel that I overstate Ororo's abilities (because I don't as I have canon PLUS interviews to back up what I say regarding Storm's power levels). Want to know what irks him? His words to me on IM a while back (we have not chatted in a bit), "Storm is a character who can easily become another Phoenix or Isis, but I don't think she should be that powerful." Now, I'm quoting from memory, but those are his exact words to me. I don't know who Isis is, but he told me she was some DC character. He believes Claremont overdid it with Storm. Me, I think she merely got her due and since its in canon, I'm not gonna let it go. Besides, other writers have touched up on the foundation Claremont has established for Storm and we see glimpses of this potential from time to time. On top of that, just last week, I tweeted Yost about possibilities of Storm having huge feats in "Amazing X-Men" since he just took over that title last month. He tweeted back to me that he "lives to give Storm big feats." He was singing my song and I'm dancing to the tune. Marvel is going to get my money for that book! They are doing exactly what they need to do to get me to open up my wallet for that title!
4) Regarding that Booshman guy, Genki, Salustrade and the others on that list you mentioned who are being rude to me, I don't have to be rude back to them because I have the facts on my side. (Earlier on, when I was irked, yeah, I said some not-too-nice things in response to some attacks upon me, but then I figure its not worth it.) Storm IS all that and a biscuit. If they are jealous of the fact that she is the First Lady of Marvel, that's their problem for their Storm hating, not mine. They just don't want Storm to be great because she's not married to Panther right now. I'm just telling it like it is. Booshman is mad because when he came up with his anti-Storm stuff, I took out a can of "what for" and socked it to him. Notice, I didn't have to call him names, or curse him out (which I don't do to anyone on the internet or in real life) or make any real personal insults upon his person like he does to me except calling him desperate (which he is), ignorant and jealous. When folks on here tried to holler that if Ororo were paired with Peter Parker instead of T'challa how everyone would be saying that he's too good for her, I took care of that and showed how she's too good for Peter. Here's the facts: Storm's got her own solo series going on now with a HUGE fan of hers back from the early Claremontian days writing the book with a MASSIVE Storm fanatic, Daniel Ketchum, editing the book. Ketchum told Pak to write down a list of huge Storm feats he wants to see Storm do in her solo. On top of this, Pak is going to pit Storm against "gods" (and, no, these are not going to be low level "gods" that Spidey and Logan can fight, you can take that to the bank) and has stated she has the power to take on any of Marvel's big guns. (Side note: Pak is a Black Panther fan as well. I fully expect that he is going to have Panther show up in her book for an issue or two and the two of them will be portrayed very well together if this happens. Personally, from a business perspective and for the sake of readership, I think it would be best if Pak waited till the second year of the title to have Panther show up.) Yost is going to give Storm powerful feats and everything. I agree with those of you who say that Storm has been poorly portrayed in comics the last few years. That's why I dropped comics for the last 2-3 years, but just got back into them after the
Storm solo was announced back in April. Many critics, people at Marvel and folks across the internet all say that Storm is the premier female character at Marvel. Seems to me she is about to get her due. She's poised to get the respect she deserves...FINALLY. So, people like Salustrade just look petty and ridiculous when they go posting scans of Storm at her low point to try and make the character look bad with all of this positive energy going on around this character right now as they talk about how "Black characters need to get respected at Marvel". LOL, give me a break. He's posting those pictures not because he's trying to take a shot at Marvel, but because he wants to take a shot at the character herself. It comes across like sour grapes.