There is a very interesting thread on CBR which pretty much sums up what I have seen anecdotally with T’challa and why I have always been a huge advocate of him getting upgraded and having better feats and Why I think he isn’t A-list.
T’challa is one of those rare characters that has pretty much everything, his personality, background, upbringing, iconic outfit and more. But his power-set and how he gets his powers is very, very convoluted and does not really make much sense. For a lot of people it’s one thing that turns them off, they get to the point where they are like cool, cool, cool, then when they see this power-set it’s a huge let down. Powers usually does not make the character, but for some reason in T’challa case it does (along with lack of feats).
Let me explain.
T’challa becoming Peak-Human from the Heart Shape Herb has *never* made sense to me (or a lot of people for that matter). While this does not take into account all its nuances, in its simplest explanation the HSH was the Wakandan “super soldier formula” but not as good. This is how it was and has been presented for years. This sort of thing was a big factor in the destruction of the character post Lee/Kirby. Not that he had those powers then, but comic-fandom rules came along Cap was THE Peak Human. In tandem with writers after Lee/Kirby/McGregor striping away all the cleverness and technology from T’challa, young fans would see this guy in the extremely cool outfit, only to find out he was only human and jumped around a lot. He fought Klaw when he came around and that’s it (The lame avengers run by Roy Thomas, thank god for Mr. Priest ret conning it).
Even if he was shown to be just ‘below’ Captain America (who’s SSF put him at the very highest possible level of Peak Human) you had characters like Daredevil, Hawkeye, etc who seem just as fast, if not faster… and feats who’s were far better then ‘Peak-human’ T’challa. It made no sense, this was killing the character. He had pretty much everything, but for a long time he was just a guy jumping around in a cat suit that everyone the comic (the characters) said was cool, but whose feats where not all that great when compared to the A-list heroes, B-list even. He was not the guy from FF #52, but someone else. A character with so much potential, stuck in the background. He was still cool, but he was stuck there.
Captain America being Peak Human from the SSF makes sense for Steve Rogers; who was a sickly, geeky kid who became the pinnacle of human perfection for America during WW2, when he joined the SS program while trying to help America. But for T’challa it made no sense. He’s royalty and was not some sickly child. He was raised and trained from Birth. If Daredevil and so many others could attain peak human status or near it without any substance, while at the same time having feats that far out classed T’challa, understand that this is a huge factor in some comic fans not respecting the character at all. After Lee/Kirby/Donald McGregor and Before C. J Priest he (T’ challa) was totally stripped of all technology and was not a prep master, just a human acrobat in a cat suit that jumped around. The guy standing in the back ground of all the other Avengers. Priest received a lot of hate for returning T’challa to his roots, T’challa was the biggest bad ass in Marvel period, but other books did not honor it. Understand that this is the real reason why Mr. Hudlin gets a lot of flack, because he was having none of That B.S…his run was a big F-u to all the haters out there of the character. He did it his way…and he was the first writer (Jason Aaron followed up nicely) that did not hold back with T’challa. While Priest explained everything, Mr. Hudlin didn’t. Good or bad, I understood why. Spiderman does not explain, neither does Batman. Why should T’challa??? None of these characters are with limits, for example Wolverine. He does something above his level and its cool….but T’challa always seems to have them.
Still the convoluted background of his powers linger.
Donald McGregor did a great job trying to explain and define the Heart Shape Herb so it would make sense.
"The poultice stimulated and accentuated the human being's kinesthetic sense. The kinesthetic sense is the subliminal perception that allows human beings to close their eyes, yet know where the different parts of their bodies are. If you didn't have this sense, you couldn't pick your nose or wash your hair if your eyes weren't open. The poultice, plus the stimuli of rigorous theological and physical training, heightened your kinesthetic sense. It heightens the proprioceptors (the proprioceptive system processes the orientation sense to the brain) and perceptions in your body. That is how you sense where a tree limb or a building edge is, know exactly where it is and never have a moment's doubt that your fingers will close about it...The sacred anointment poultice has a second effect on your muscles and ligaments, specifically on the joints where bones connect and swivel, mesh and respond. There are receptors in these joints called the Pacinian corpuscles that carry the signal to the brain to fulfill proper movement. Somehow the poultice is absorbed into those receptors and makes them especially sensitive...This is what enables you to twist and dodge with unparalleled grace."
--- Donald McGregor - Panthers Prey

“In truth, he had been content with the knowledge that the religious rituals had even him a spiritual strength that has in turn enhanced his physical prowess”
McGregor accomplished separating the Heart Shape Herb from the Super Soldier formula, however when other writers dumbed down his explanation, it also made T’challa the Wakandan Captain America, only he was weaker (and Steve still had far better feats). Gone was the spiritual strength to enhance his physical prowess, the HSH just turned him peak human, and he could jump around a lot. Priest followed McGregor, but by then what I just explained pretty much was negated.
Hudlin made T’challa a product of Royal Wakandan eugenics, but did not touch on the HSH much until the first arc of this volume. The eugenics and warrior training in this volume in my opinion has raised the character up, and giving him new life. Still the issue of the HSH turning someone peak human who should be able to attain peak human status without it is troubling. T’challa and Shuri both should be peak human before they even take the herb. But then that leaves the herb only giving them superhumanly acute senses, which is why McGregor’s explanation was always the best. T’challa’s reflexes, the way he moves, twist and turns, the fact that he can jump and know where to put out his hand without even thinking about it are what the HSH should be about about. Peak Human Status should not even factor in at all.
Also the fact that BAST is granting the power also does not make sense. Why would the Panther god only give his/her top follower peak human ability? That does not make sense at all. This makes T’challa look weak in my opinion. it also makes Bast look weak too. Daredevil and many others become Peak human without it, so does Batman and many other DC and Marvel heroes in tandem with better feats.
So the upgrade is pretty awesome to me. 1 ton is great; he does not have to be as strong as Spiderman. Spider-Man is able to lift almost 10 tons at maximum effort. The question is if T’challa’s maximum effort is 1 ton versus 1 ton being his base strength (with his maximum effort falling short of Spiderman at about like 5 tons). That latter is the better upgrade. If his maximum effort strength is 1 ton then that is very disappointing. The better way would be to just state his base level, and not give a real limit to who far he can push himself, but make the limit that is decent like 4-5 tons but he could suffer structural damage to his body as the reason why he does not do this.
Like I said, 1 ton is great, but my focus though is on speed. Speed kills, and T’challa’s speed should be on par with Spiderman. Most who have longed for an upgrade almost never site lifting power or his strength. Even if his max was 1 ton, his speed should be his best physical power.

One thing that does make me kind of weary is turning him into triathlon 2.0. Spider-Man's reflexes are some where around 15 to 18 times that of a normal human and them making T’challa being only 3 or 4 is just making him triathlon physically. I fear that is how it will be viewed. It ready has by some.
When folks compare T’challa to another hero it’s mostly DC’s Batman. The comparison is from the right family. T’challa should be compared and more a long the lines of Cassandra Cain (former Batgirl). That is my new beating drum. She is extremely popular for a reason. She is ‘peak human’ but she performs what many think T’challa should be able to do. If T'challa had her feats he would be one of the most popular heroes at Marvel and yes A-list. So I will start posting them for debate.
Feats and good powers explaintion = closer to A- list.